Fact Check: Is demand for palm tree driving massive deforestation?

 

Ruth Orji

Claim: Demand for palm trees is driving massive deforestation.

A few years ago, @TheYearsProject, a YouTube page did a documentary featuring the legendary Harrison Ford on how the high demand for palm trees is driving deforestation in places.

https://youtu.be/54dmDQsSqrU?si=wzIwDfo6QLQoMlmc

This post has since gathered 67,481 views; 855 likes; 173 comments; 60 shares.

NatureNews, Africa’s foremost newspaper on climate change, which is dedicated to providing accurate insights to stop the spread of fake news particularly among users of social media, subjected the claim to fact checking.

Findings: Using the Google search tool in conducting this research, NatureFact, the fact checking unit of NatureNews, accessed a few papers and studies.

A thorough fact-checking investigation has revealed that this claim is true.

@dgaillrd argues that palm trees are economically friendly coz of it’s high demand for production of consumables, it however is environmentally unfriendly because it leads to biodiversity loss and deforestation.

https://youtube.com/shorts/WTZCLnv1Dhs?si=l0up7uTBlW0pagTR

@climatetruth states that to accommodate this growing demand, habitats as well as a lot of trees have to be destroyed to establish vast expanse of palm plantations leading to biodiversity loss as well as deforestation especially in Indonesia and Malaysia, the largest producers of palm oil in the world accounting for 85% of the total amount.

https://youtu.be/HaqVyLLyA8s?si=2ps9ilz6ujQvrlmz

@TakePart elucidates further that 62,000 square miles of land are burnt and cleared every year to create more lands for palm plantation, therefore creating habitat loss, the death of millions- if not billions of biodiversity (especially orangutans) and also the release of 2 billion tons of carbon emissions into the air contributing to climate change.

https://youtu.be/LSumTLrJzdU?si=xGzYD1w_SRiWZcSY

@NewVorld agrees to this

https://youtube.com/shorts/bw6o2GbYRMg?si=4RzaUkHHlmBKH3qT

@garimajain6656 narrates the hazards of palm plantations in Malaysia

https://youtube.com/shorts/hUQX1rVdmsg?si=yPpshWm0x-pU4uqF

The internet is agog with inferences of how palm plantation is creating deforestation due to its high demand.

These lands that are burnt, cleared and bulldozed are still reforested but just with palms instead of a litany of different trees. So, there are less palm trees for more trees that are killed. Aside, from deforestation, the method of clearing these lands leaves much to be desired. The burning not only eliminates biodiversity but also emits a large amount of green house gases of CO2 into the atmosphere. No proper methods of transferring endangered species (orangutans, tigers, etc) is been effected which brought about the mantra “Earth is not just for humans”.

It is also pertinent to mention some popular palm species and their productive lifespans:

1. Date Palm (Phoenix dactylifera): 50-100 years

– Begins producing fruit within 3-5 years after planting

– Peaks at 10-15 years, producing 100-200 kg (220-440 lbs) of dates per year

– Gradually declines after 30-40 years

2. Coconut Palm (Cocos nucifera): 50-80 years

– Begins producing coconuts within 5-7 years after planting

– Peaks at 10-20 years, producing 75-100 coconuts per year

– Declines after 40-50 years

3. Areca Palm (Dypsis lutescens): 30-50 years

– Begins producing betel nuts within 5-10 years after planting

– Peaks at 15-25 years, producing 20-50 kg (44-110 lbs) of betel nuts per year

– Declines after 30-40 years

4. Oil Palm (Elaeis guineensis): 25-40 years

– Begins producing oil-rich fruit within 3-5 years after planting

– Peaks at 10-20 years, producing 10-20 tons of fruit per hectare per year

– Declines after 25-30 years

Palm trees, specifically oil palm (Elaeis guineensis), have contributed to deforestation and habitat destruction, primarily due to:

Oil Palm Plantation Expansion

1. Land clearing: Forests are cleared (especially with fire) to establish oil palm plantations, leading to widespread deforestation.
2. Habitat destruction: Native species’ habitats, including orangutans, elephants, and tigers, are destroyed or fragmented.
3. Biodiversity loss; Forest ecosystems are replaced by monoculture plantations, reducing biodiversity.

 

Drivers of Deforestation

1. Demand for palm oil: Growing global demand for palm oil, used in food, cosmetics, and biofuels.
2. Economic incentives: Palm oil production is often more profitable than sustainable forestry or conservation.
3. Government policies: In some countries, policies prioritize agricultural development over environmental protection.

Affected Regions

1. Southeast Asia: Indonesia and Malaysia, accounting for 85% of global palm oil production, have experienced significant deforestation.
2. Central and South America: Palm oil expansion has led to deforestation in countries like Colombia, Ecuador, and Peru.
3. Africa: Palm oil plantations are expanding in countries like Nigeria, Ghana, and the Democratic Republic of Congo.

Consequences

1. Loss of carbon sinks: Forests absorb carbon dioxide; deforestation contributes to climate change.
2. Soil degradation: Palm oil plantations can lead to soil erosion and nutrient depletion.
3. Water pollution: Plantation runoff can contaminate water sources.
4. Indigenous community impacts: Deforestation can displace indigenous communities and threaten their livelihoods.

Sustainable Solutions

1. Certified Sustainable Palm Oil (CSPO): Encourages responsible production and certification.
2. High Conservation Value (HCV) areas: Identifies and protects areas with high biodiversity value.
3. Free Prior Informed Consent (FPIC): Ensures indigenous communities are involved in decision-making.
4. Reforestation and restoration: Efforts to restore degraded forests and promote sustainable land use.

Verdict: True. The demand for palm oil and palm trees is driving massive deforestation.