Fact Check: Does Poly Vinyl Chloride (PVC) roofing constitute health challenges?

 

Ruth Orji

Claim: Poly Vinyl Chloride (PVC) roofing constitutes health challenges.

A few years ago, X user @KellyTurnbull stated that PVC was detrimental to human health both during production and consumption.

https://x.com/Coelasquid/status/1200879212388847616?t=gpAdgpp_mqW7-xmLpl1r7g&s=08

This post has since gathered  170 likes; 3 comments; 31 retweets; 4 bookmarks.

NatureNews, Africa’s foremost newspaper on climate change, which is dedicated to providing accurate insights to stop the spread of fake news particularly among users of social media, subjected the claim to fact checking.

Findings: Using the Google search tool in conducting this research, NatureFact, the fact checking unit of NatureNews, accessed a few papers and studies.

A thorough fact-checking investigation has revealed that this claim is accurate.

@SafeWaterAdvocacy stated that when PVC is exposed to heat, it releases deadly gases that may cause combustion.

https://youtu.be/uwHRAoxhUcI?si=mjHA78jZLL2Jiis0

@FastandCurious said PVC causes a myriad of respiratory illnesses.

https://youtu.be/StlRS1cHcWM?si=GHWKNhRBMnSucOI_

@HealthyMaterialsLab states that PVC contains several carcinogens known to man.

https://youtu.be/o6-2QNywgkw?si=5ZN7aLgcR_7KDdxY

@PBS TV did an èxposé on PVC titled “Trade secrets”, an investigation on PVC as a health time bomb.

https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2001/04/pbs-a06.html?s=08

Additional information:

Some roofing materials can have negative environmental and health impacts. Here are a few examples:

Environmental Concerns:

1. Asphalt Shingles: Contribute to landfill waste, require frequent replacement, and contain petroleum products.
2. PVC (Polyvinyl Chloride) Roofing: Releases toxic chemicals during production and disposal, contributing to air and water pollution.
3. Tar and Gravel Roofing: Contains petroleum-based products, contributing to greenhouse gas emissions and potential water pollution.
4. Galvanized Steel Roofing: May contain lead, zinc, or other heavy metals, potentially leaching into waterways.

 

Health Concerns:

1. Asbestos Roofing: Contains carcinogenic fibers, posing serious health risks during installation, removal, or disturbance.
2. Lead-Based Roofing Materials: Exposure to lead can cause neurological damage, developmental issues, and organ damage.
3. Formaldehyde-Containing Roofing Materials: Off-gas formaldehyde, a known carcinogen, into indoor air.
4. PVC Roofing: Releases volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and toxic chemicals during production and decomposition.

 

Eco-Friendly Alternatives:

1. Metal Roofing (recyclable, durable)
2. Clay or Concrete Tiles (natural, sustainable)
3. Slate Roofing (durable, low maintenance)
4. Green Roofs (vegetated, reduces urban heat island effect)
5. Solar Panels (renewable energy, reduces carbon footprint)
6. Recycled Rubber Roofing
7. Bamboo Roofing
8. Cedar Shake Roofing (sustainable, naturally resistant)

 

Considerations for Sustainable Roofing:

1. Durability: Choose materials with long lifespans.
2. Recyclability: Opt for materials that can be recycled or reused.
3. Low Maintenance: Select materials requiring minimal upkeep.
4. Local Sourcing: Reduce transportation emissions by choosing locally sourced materials.
5. Energy Efficiency: Consider materials with high solar reflectance or thermal mass.

When selecting roofing materials, consult with professionals and consider factors like:

1. Climate and weather conditions
2. Budget and lifecycle costs
3. Local building codes and regulations
4. Environmental and health impacts

Verdict: True: PVC impacts negatively on our health.